ConceptualFiction.comExploring the New Reality of Fiction
Browse library

From the Conceptual Fiction archive

City by Clifford Simak

Clifford Simak's City is less a novel than a series of interlocking stories. In toto, they represent chapters from the mythology and folk tales of the ancient race of men, as preserved by the dogs.

Original archive text attributed to Ted Gioia

The fear that human beings will be displaced by some other species has been a major them in many science fiction stories. Usually this usurping power comes from outer space, although occasionally it is home-grown.

Pierre Boulle’s Planet of the Apes is a representative example of the genre, a classic account of homo sapiens finding themselves losers in the Darwinian struggle for superiority. Boulle’s experiences as a prisoner of war in World War II no doubt contribute to the ethos of this work. (And it may be worth noting that this author’s other famous book, The Bridge Over the River Kwai , is one of the great POW stories of all time.)

But Clifford Simak takes this familiar theme, and turns it on its head. The world of City is run by dogs. But instead of depicting them as vile usurprers—as we have come to expect in books of this sort—Simak makes them into nostalgic, tender-hearted creatures who miss the “good old days” when a dog was man’s best friend. Simak plays on all the positive canine traits of loyalty, dependability, protectiveness and affection in creating his kennel of characters.

City is less a novel than a series of interlocking stories. In toto, they represent chapters from the mythology and folk tales of the ancient race of men, as preserved by the dogs. Simak, with surprising deconstructive flair, even offers notes from the canine editors, who sometimes struggle to understand the tales of humans that have been passed down to them, paw to paw, through the ages.

Simak uses this framing device to show how humans lost their edge, moving away from the cities when the spread of family air transports allowed them to live in more isolated rural areas. The sociological models here are fuzzy and unconvincing, and the human characters in the book fairly one dimensional. Yet the book compensates for these limitations through its conceptual originality, sketching man-and-dog symbiotic relationships beyond the wildest dreams of Lassie or Rin-Tin-Tin.

Bruce Webster is an especially cherished human in this folklore. He made the surgical modifications that allowed dogs to speak (although with a bit of a Scooby Do lisp), and later generations of Websters become so important in the canine imagination that homo sapiens come to be called websters. Into this mix, Simak tosses in other characters— dogs, robots, mutants and even some very smart ants.

This book is more noteworthy for its individual parts than for its overall coherence. I can’t help thinking that Simak took several different story ideas, and tried to force them together into a single narrative. Some of the best parts of the book—for example, an interesting interlude focusing on a scientist and his dog on Jupiter— could have worked just as well as a short story, and the attempt to fuse them into an over-arching plot seems strained.

Nonetheless, this is an inventive book, with no shortage of interesting twists and turns. The pacing and constant plot shift keep City interesting, and while this may not be the great sci-fi masterpiece that some have made it, it will continue to charm readers. Especially those who buy dog-food in bulk.