ConceptualFiction.comExploring the New Reality of Fiction
Browse library

From the Conceptual Fiction archive

Dhalgren by Samuel R. Delany

Samuel Delany asked for an analytics of attention rather than a calculus of form. Ted Gioia reviews Dhalgren, the novel that sets out to deliver exactly that.

Original archive text attributed to Ted Gioia

Face it, books are too damn long. Especially 800- page novels like Samuel R. Delany's Dhalgren . Even book reviews need to get shorter—or so I judge by watching the Incredible Shrinking Coverage of fiction in the daily fishwrap. Editors agree: anything longer than a text message nowadays is only good for trimming and skimming.

What’s a literary critic to do? Well, I have noticed that short quotes from books are very popular on the emerging media. After all, why read a 800- page novel, when you can savor the best passages in 140-character tweets? With that in mind, I have distilled Mr. Delany's Dhalgren into some bite-size extracts suitable for Twitter.

How about these?

"Pavement sausages split; the cabbage remembers." Samuel R. Delany

"Only for a distance in civet furrow, here hid awfully just a million savants at the pot." Samuel R. Delany

"Your rosamundus may mathematik him, but it won’t move me one mechanical apple corer." Samuel R. Delany

"Get with-it, mauve-peanut! Make it, thing-a-ma- boob!" Samuel R. Delany

And my favorite bit of advice from our author— just the inspiring comment you need to start out the day: "French fried pickelilly and deep-dish-apple death won’t get you through that wake up in the morning alive." Samuel R. Delany

And that's why I stick with a cup of coffee in the morning.

Ah, I know what you're thinking. You're worried that a tiny quote can't do justice to such a big, ambitious book. To that I respond, in the words of Samuel Delany, "What we need is not a calculus of form but an analytics of attention, which renders form on the indifferent and undifferentiated pleroma."

Did you get that?

Okay, some folks will want to read the whole dang thing-a-ma-boob. Delany sets the tone from the opening three sentences:

to wound the autumnal city. So howled out for the world to give him a name. The in-dark answered with the wind.

And if you didn't appreciate it sufficiently the first time, you will get a second chance eighty pages later, when the protagonist finds a handwritten journal which he decides to peruse. The opening page begins: "to wound the autumnal city…" We're back where we started. And after you've trudged your way from page 80 to page 800, you may think you still haven’t gone too far.

You want to know more about the protagonist? Well, there’s not much too say. He doesn't know his age, his name, his purpose. People call him Kidd. Or some people call him the Kid. His setting is almost as ambiguous as his past. He has arrived in the post-apocalyptic city Bellona, where a few straggling survivors contrive makeshift existences in the aftermath of….Well, I haven’t figured that one out. Something bad must have happened in Bellona, but if author Delany knows what it is, he ain't telling.

But Bellona is a strange city. "I go down a street: buildings are burning," remarks one of the aimless drifters who pass as characters in this book. "I go down the same street the next day. They’re still burning. Two weeks later, I go down the same street and nothing looks like it’s been burned at all. Maybe time is just running backward here. Or sideways. But that’s impossible too." Strange things are also happening in the sky. Morning light comes from different directions, depending on the day. On a rare evening, when the smoke and haze clear, two moons are seen in the sky. A few days later, the sun grows to huge proportions, yet the temperature doesn't change. Then the sun subsides, and the haze returns.

Dhalgren is classified as science fiction, but the book is more akin to magical realism. Readers looking for advanced technologies will be disappointed. Early in the novel, one of the character brags about his microwave oven. "You can roast a whole rib roast in ten, twenty minutes." This is about as fancy as gadgets get in Delany's book, except for your stray holograms—who populate this novel the way stray dogs do in other cities. An astronaut appears midway through the novel, but we meet him in the local bar. During the course of these pages, he never quite gets off the ground. Much like Dhalgren itself.

I'd like to tell you the plot of Dhalgren , but I'm really not sure whether this book has one. Delany does provide incidents, but the reader will struggle just to put them in chronological order. Frankly, I'm not convinced that chronology exists in this book. The dates in the local Bellona newspaper jump around more than a week's worth of the History Channel on Tivo. In the closing pages, Delany makes it even harder to sort out before-and -after, cause-and-effect, by placing two narratives next to each other on the same page. But, hey, the absence of plot, chronology and character development make this book all the more suited for reduction to bite-sized tweets, no?

Okay, there is plenty of raunchy stuff here. At the very start, we get some explicit couplings, and then Delany moves on to triplings and more-lings. But those ferreting out concupiscence, will find sometimes find it wrapped in passages such as: "All efforts, dying here, coalesce in the blockage of ear and throat, to an a-corporal lucence, a patterning released from pleasure, the retained shadow of pure idea."

And that’s all I have to say about that.

Occasionally Delany relents, and provides some semblance of story, or an interesting character, or some thoughtful interlude. But these never last long. The most fascinating person in the book, the local newspaper editor, never shows his face once. Who can blame him? His insightful ruminations don’t really fit with the rest of Dhalgren . He really ought to request a transfer to some other, more coherent story. Dhalgren the novel is, instead, like the city Bellona where it is set: a smoking ruin where order and clarity are only a dim memory, and confusion reigns.

Are you ready for 800-pages of this? Be my guest! But I have a hunch you will be back for the tweets.

Ted Gioia writes on music, books and popular culture. His most recent book is The Birth (and Death) of the Cool .