Was Samuel Johnson (1709-1784) the first to dismiss conceptual fiction as a gimmick? The great critic, poet and lexicographer offered up this pithy assessment of Jonathan Swift's Gulliver’s Travels (1726). “When once you have thought of big men and little men, it is very easy to do all the rest.” Since Johnson's time, similarly curt brush-offs have been given to countless works of fantasy and science fiction, these books' grand imaginative leaps offered as the very reason why we can safely ignore them.
I’ve learned a lot from Samuel Johnson—in fact, he may have influenced my writing about art and culture more than anyone—but he was dead wrong in this instance. Perhaps Mr. Johnson never finished the novel, because the most incisive and thought-provoking moments in Gulliver's Travels arrive not in the early sections on the "little men" (the Lilliputians) and the “big men” (the Brobdingnagians), but in the closing chapters, where Swift's social satire and political commentary take over a work that started out as a slightly modernized fairy tale.
(By the way, has anyone else noticed how often books get remembered for some incident in the opening pages? Don Quixote lasts a thousand pages, but the titling at windmills scene, almost at the start, gets all the attention. Proust takes readers on a two-thousand-page literary journey, but that early scene with the madeleine has become emblematic of the whole work. The same is true with Gulliver and his Lilliputian adversaries. A cynical critic could make a case that literary history and theory is driven by the first 5% of our classic works.)
The opening pages of Gulliver's Travels are especially misleading, presenting a quasi-Dr. Seussian scenario that has inspired many later commentators to classify this work as a story for youngsters. And a psychoanalytical interpretation might well back up this reading, decoding Gulliver's entrapment by the tiny Lilliputians as a kind of wish fulfillment for the tiniest of readers. Yet the teachings of Dr. Freud notwithstanding, Dr. Swift (PhD in Divinity, 1702) did not write a book for adolescents and early teens. Yes, he deserves ample praise—as I make clear below—for his important contributions to three different schools of genre fiction: fantasy, sci-fi and the adventure story. But Swift is also much more than a spinner of engaging yarns. The non-realistic elements of his novel are never inserted merely to dazzle or charm the reader. At every stage of Gulliver's Travels , the fantastic elements are subservient to Swift’s satire and critical thinking.
Swift is hardly an exception in this regard. Almost from the birth of storytelling, works of imaginative fiction have served as powerful platforms for social commentary. This was true of Ovid and Homer, Apuleius and Rabelais , H.G. Wells and Olaf Stapledon, Aldous Huxley and George Orwell, Margaret Atwood and Robert Heinlein , all the way to the present day, when science fiction and fantasy themes have taken over a host of mainstream highbrow literary works, from Infinite Jest to The Road . Are you surprised? You shouldn't be. Readers should expect brave new ideas to spring from the same writers who are the boldest at re-imagining the fabric and conventions of the mundane world.
Yet Swift stands out, even among this elite company, as the boldest satirist of them all. In Gulliver’'s Travels , he found a simple and delightful vehicle for his most pointed barbs— namely Lemuel Gulliver's attempts to explain his own flawed civilization to the many new people he meets. Those who classify Gulliver's Travels as a story for youngsters—one of most misguided rebranding efforts in literary history (and not just for the many crude and scatological passages)—or a bit of escapism or idle entertainment, thus miss the main point. The freshest and most courageous passages in this book have nothing to do with Lilliputians or Brobdingnagians, but with a much different race, known as the British.
Here are some choice passages that are hardly kid’s stuff.
First, Gulliver needs to convey the distinctive characteristics of the noble class, which his interlocutor assumes must encompass the must virtuous and praiseworthy individuals in the realm. Not so, Gulliver explains:
Nobility, among us, was altogether a different thing from the idea he had of it; that our young noblemen are bred from their childhood in idleness and luxury; that, as soon as years will permit, they consume their vigour, and contract odious diseases among lewd females; and when their fortunes are almost ruined, they marry some woman of mean birth, disagreeable person, and unsound constitution (merely for the sake of money), whom they hate and despise. That the productions of such marriages are generally scrofulous, rickety, or deformed children; by which means the family seldom continues above three generations, unless the wife takes care to provide a healthy father, among her neighbours or domestics, in order to improve and continue the breed….
Next, Gulliver struggles to explain the conflicts of nations to his host:
He asked me, ‘what were the usual causes or motives that made one country go to war with another?’ I answered ‘they were innumerable; but I should only mention a few of the chief. Sometimes the ambition of princes, who never think they have land or people enough to govern; sometimes the corruption of ministers, who engage their master in a war, in order to stifle or divert the clamour of the subjects against their evil administration. Difference in opinions has cost many millions of lives: for instance, whether flesh be bread, or bread be flesh; whether the juice of a certain berry be blood or wine; whether whistling be a vice or a virtue; whether it be better to kiss a post, or throw it into the fire; what is the best colour for a coat, whether black, white, red, or gray; and whether it should be long or short, narrow or wide, dirty or clean; with many more. Neither are any wars so furious and bloody, or of so long a continuance, as those occasioned by difference in opinion, especially if it be in things indifferent.’
Finally Gulliver takes on the most difficult task of all—namely, describing the workings of a court of law:
I said there was a society of men among us, bred up from their youth in the art of proving by words multiplied for the purpose, that white is black, and black is white, according as they are paid. To this society all the rest of the people are slaves. For example, if my neighbour hath a mind to my cow, he hires a lawyer to prove that he ought to have my cow from me. I must then hire another to defend my right, it being against the rules of law that any man should be allowed to speak for himself. Now in this case, I who am the true owner lie under two great disadvantages. First; my lawyer, being practised almost from his cradle in defending falsehood, is quite out of his element when he would be an advocate for justice, which as an office unnatural, he always attempts with great awkwardness, if not with ill-will. The second disadvantage is, that my lawyer must proceed with great caution, or else he will be reprimanded by the Judges, and abhorred by his brethren, as one who would lessen the practice of the law. And therefore I have but two methods to preserve my cow. The first is to gain over my adversary's lawyer with a double fee, who will then betray his client by insinuating that he hath justice on his side. The second way is for my lawyer to make my cause appear as unjust as he can, by allowing the cow to belong to my adversary; and this if it be skilfully done will certainly bespeak the favour of the Bench.
Each of these passages comes from the final section of Gulliver's Travels , which describes that narrator's visit to the Houyhnhnms —a race of rational horses who live alongside brutish human beings known as Yahoos (note Swift's contribution both to our vocabulary and the Internet age). A modern-day filmmaker would find little sustenance in this part of Swift's story; the scenes are little more than springboards for dialogue and discourse, without the striking opportunity for 'special effects' provided by the 'little people' and 'big people' in the earlier chapters. But those who are familiar with the cantankerous spirit of Jonathan Swift know full well that he was capable of his own kind of 'special effects'—with no advanced software or stop-motion animation required.
Yet for all the satire, Swift also set the stage for the later blossoming of genre literature. Gulliver’s Travels is very much a forerunner of the later adventure stories of H. Rider Haggard and Rudyard Kipling—and reminds us that travel literature set the blueprint for many pulp fiction formulas. The fantasy genre is also very much an extension of such works— how many of them even come with a map as frontispiece? Certainly Gulliver's Travels is an important part of that lineage as well. Still another genre is anticipated in these pages: in the section on Gulliver’s visit to the flying island of Laputa, Swift moves clearly on to the terrain of science fiction. His explanations of the magnetic principles that allow the flying island to elevate and move may not be scientifically sound, but the very fact that our author felt compelled to provide technological descriptions is revealing. The storytellers who gave us the Arabian Nights or Grimm’s Fairy Tales never felt the need to bring science to the aid of their fantastic stories, and Swift’s gesture here, ever so fleeting, points the way towards the later mindset of a Jules Verne or H.G. Wells .
So we are not wrong to draw a connection all the way from Gulliver's Travels to modern day fabulists, from J. R. R. Tolkien to J.K. Rowling . But the fanciful elements in Gulliver's Travels should never blind us to the acerbic satire that made this work a masterpiece. Swift’s greatest achievement—and one can we can still learn from—is to have written a book of far-flung travels that always hits home the hardest. Indeed, even Samuel Johnson should have figured out that Swift's genius came from putting down to size all those 'little people' who have never been anywhere near Lilliput.
Ted Gioia writes on music, literature, and popular culture. His newest book is The Jazz Standards: A Guide to the Repertoire .