Those who espouse scrupulous realism as the ultimate goal of the novel rarely give much thought to science fiction. Sci-fi, after all, represents the antithesis of realism.
Or does it? A handful of science fiction authors have advocated a so-called "hard" approach, one in which fanciful and extravagant notions are pruned away, leaving behind plausible future histories in which each scenario and equation possesses the ring of truth, or at least plausibility. (Example: Stanislaw Lem’s His Master’s Voice .) An even smaller cadre of genre writers ha s constructed quasi-realist character-driven stories, in which the human element p ushes the plot forward, and technology is only a platform for the novel and not—as with so much sci-fi —its raison d'être. (Example: Daniel Keyes’ Flowers for Algernon .) Still others have turned to the social sciences, constructing future- oriented stories that achieve verisimilitude through their acute comprehension of group dynamics and the influence of institutions on our personal narratives. (Example: Ursula Le Guin's The L eft Hand of Darkness .)
But no science fiction author has done a better job of integrating all of these approaches into a vivid, holistic style than Kim Stanley Robinson. Perhaps the best measure of his fidelity to realism is the fifteen years R obinson spent researching Mars as part of his effort to enhance the plausibility of his Mars trilogy— Red Mars (1992), Green Mars (1993) and Blue Mars (1996). The end result is that strange variant on the landscape novel, one in which our author seems as much at home taking us on a tour of Noctis Labyrinthus or Olympus Mons as William Faulkner is describing Yoknapatawpha County or Cormac McCarthy the Tex-Mex borderlands.
These novels are geologically rich and scientifically informed, but Robinson’s approach is essentially ecological . He understands that all landscapes are parts of larger systems, and that inhabitants stand out as the decisive inputs in shaping and giving meaning to any terrain, whether right outside our doorstep or on another planet. Those interrelationships constitute, in a nutshell, the core focus of the Mars trilogy, Robinson's realism enhanced by his constant grounding of technology in the psychological and ideological leanings of the people who wield it. This in itself is a noteworthy achievement within the context of the science fiction genre, which usually turns the cause-and-effect relationship upside down—forcing characters to act as unwitting extensions of the high tech concepts that drive the plot. But Robinson is even more exemplary in his grasp of the nuances of the personal motivations at work in large-scale social engineering. Bad things happen in this book, as they do in all novels, but instead of falling back on the simple good-versus-evil stick figures of most genre works, Robinson shows how dreams, hopes, and good intentions can have mixed or disastrous results through compromise, naïveté or—that most powerful force in human history—the law of unintended consequences.
Red Mars chronicles the efforts of a multinational force, under the direction of the United Nations, to colonize another planet. Think you've seen it before? Not, really. Robinson dispenses with the usual tricks of the trade. Hence you won’t find little green men here, or extraterrestrial life of any sort; no strange viruses or rad high-tech weapons; no death stars or evil galactic empires; no warps in the fabric of the universe or wrinkles in time or wormholes to other space-time continuums. The biggest obstacles to success faced by the fledgling Martian colony come from familiar human foibles: conflicting visions of community organization, incompatible agendas, flawed institutional structures, and the usual problems resulting from what philosopher Karl Popper called "holistic social engineering."
In fact, this work could serve as eloquent testimony to Popper’s advocacy of a "piecemeal" approach to manipulating complex systems, since—as that philosopher points out in The Poverty of Historicism —the complexities of large-scale change inevitable prove beyond our capability of managing. "Even with the best intentions of making heaven on earth," Popper writes, "it only succeeds in making it hell—that hell which man alone prepares for his fellow-men." Change the word "Earth" to "Mars" in this sentence, and you have a tweet-sized summary of Robinson’s novel. In his stirring narrative, the degree of change that the colonists, and later waves of transplanetary migrants, impose on Mars makes the machinations of the French and Bolshevik revolutions, which so disturbed Popper, seem like mere child’s play. Powerful interests not only jockey to impose their preferred legal, financial and political structures, but the very ground underfoot and atmosphere overhead are equally in flux, micro-managed by those who inevitably become intoxicated by the potential to remake a whole world. It is to Robinson’s credit that he brings each of these spheres of power and influence into his story, from the economic to ecological, and without ever getting preachy or academic. Each schema and ideology plays out in plausible human terms.
Robinson allows his story to unfold gradually— Red Mars takes place over a period of several decades— and he frequently lingers over interludes that other genre writers would pass over quickly or ignore completely. A lengthy section on the training simulations for the Mars landing shows off this author at his finest—and his most typical. This part of the story plays no part in pushing ahead the larger plot, but with Robinson the digressions often provide much of the fun. His concept here is a simple one: an obsessed programmer forces the crew to work through a host of unlikely and almost impossible landing constraints in various simulations, most of them resulting in a crash landing and the death of every astronaut. Robinson lavishes ample creativity and know-how on this modest sub-plot, and the end result could almost stand alone as a short story.
Another digression offers an analysis of the psychological profiles of the colonists via an ingenious framework that marries modern structuralist schemas with the ancients’ theory of the four human temperaments (sanguine, choleric, melancholic and phlegmatic). We encounter many similarly well- crafted sections throughout Red Mars, with interludes offered up on the complexities of constructing habitats, repairing drilling equipment, screening potential astronauts, as well as a host of other situations that might sound dry to you, but which present ample drama in the context of Red Mars. In short, this author does not require an exploding death star to keep his readers turning the pages.
But just when they might conclude that Robinson has renounced the plot-driven fireworks that are so typical of the outer space genre, he surprises them with a cascading series of dramatic events that give momentum to the final third of Red Mars . Here our author pulls out all the stops, and readers are treated to cataclysmic incidents of Hollywood proportions. But the sobering reality is that no grand villain or adversarial alien empire was required to do the worst damage here. All the ingredients for disaster were implicit in the conflicting agendas of the first colonists. In this sense, Robinson’s Mars has become an extension of the same problems we face on planet Earth in the here and now.
So there is a message in this book, but not a heavy- handed one, nor one that—as so often happens in message-driven novels—weighs down the narrative with pre-packaged polemics. This book is also a fine example of story-telling, well plotted, carefully paced, coherently constructed. In short, Kim Stanley Robinson has given us that rare and artful combination, a work of speculative fiction that pushes our imagination both outward and inward, allowing us to envision a totally new world and forcing us also to reconsider the old one around us.