ConceptualFiction.comExploring the New Reality of Fiction
Browse library

From the Conceptual Fiction archive

Is The Castle of Otranto the Clumsiest Classic Novel?

The best passages are empty formulas, while the worst veer into the ridiculous. In the opening pages, the heir of Otranto is killed on his wedding day when a giant helmet falls from the sky and squishes him into a pulp.

Original archive text attributed to Ted Gioia

No British writer from the 18th century is harder to pin down than Horace Walpole? Walpole espoused conventional religious views, but atheists cite him as one of their own. His political affiliations were even more misleading: Walpole represented a district in Parliament, but he never stepped foot in it. He appeared to live a celibate life, but many nowadays think that was a ruse—although the experts can’t agree on what exactly happened behind closed doors. By the way, Walpole lived in a marvelous but sham Gothic home that he loved to display—one commentator has called it "a mock-castle of a fake dynasty"—but he preferred to go into hiding whenever sightseers arrived.

Ah, Walpole also hid himself in his writings, which were perhaps his greatest deception of them all. What do we conclude from his decision to write his play The Mysterious Mother in secrecy…but then spread rumors that he had written something too disgusting for publication or staging? Or how are we to evaluate his Hieroglyphic Tales , which anticipate the 20th century absurdist movement? He only printed seven copies, and claimed that the tales were written when he was ‘out of his senses’. Yet a closer inspection shows that he was very much in earnest about these apparently frivolous narratives. And, finally, how do we deal with Walpole’s most famous book The Castle of Otranto , a novel which he pretended was the translation of a manuscript from 1529—based in turn on a story that dated back to the time of the Crusades?

Those were simply tall tales. Walpole actually wrote The Castle of Otranto , and after the success the book enjoyed upon its publication in 1764—in which it was presented as "A Story. Translated by William Marshal, Gent. From the Original Italian of Onuphrio Muralto"—Walpole decided that he wanted credit, after all, for his bestseller. For the second edition, published four months later, Walpole declared his authorship.

Yet the tables quickly turned on our author. Critics now criticized The Castle of Otranto . John Langhorne, who had initially praised the work, now denounced it as ‘'false' and 'preposterous' and condemned Walpole for "re-establishing the barbarous superstitions of Gothic devilism." Thomas Babington Macaulay would later dismiss the novel as “extravagant nonsense.” Who knows how this book would be perceived nowadays without the intervention of Sir Walter Scott, who lauded the novel as "the first modern attempt to found a tale of amusing fiction upon the basis of the ancient romances of chivalry." Scott no doubt saw his own literary successes as following the precedent set by Walpole a half-century before.

Was it fair for critics to change their mind about Walpole’s book after they learned his authorship? In most instances, this about-face would seem to invalidate a commentator's opinion. But in this case, the question of authorship and the date of composition are essential to our assessment of The Castle of Otranto. I would be willing to forgive stilted dialogue and flat characters in a chronicle from medieval times—the historical value would outweigh the limitations of the prose, and the cultural context would sufficiently explain the shortcomings of the work. Recall that this era relied on allegory—in which characters took on the names and attributes of the qualities they evoked, such as Truth or Conscience or Reason (in the case of Piers Plowman )—because this was the closest they could approach to what, today, we would call psychology or the inner life of the protagonists. Yet this approach imposed a terrible limitation on a story: once a character was defined in terms of a single attribute, change or maturation was impossible and the future complications in the drama became tiringly predictable. Despite these restrictions, allegories could still have some value for readers, but perhaps more for the medieval mind than our own. And there were good reasons why allegories were abandoned by most storytellers after the Enlightenment. The human psyche deserved better than to be treated as a one-trick pony.

For this reason, The Castle of Otranto starts to smell funny once we understand that it was written by an 18th century author. There isn’t a single moment in this novel that rings true as a study of actual human or social life. Every bit of dialogue comes across as a formulaic set piece conveying received ideas, most of them the tired concepts of chivalry and courtly love that Cervantes and Shakespeare had displaced 150 years before Walpole published his book.

Here is a taste of the dialogue, from an early scene in which Princess Isabella is attempting to flee the castle, and encounters a helpful stranger:

"Sir, whoever you are, take pity on a wretched Princess, standing on the brink of destruction. Assist me to escape from this fatal castle, or in a few moments I may be made miserable for ever."

"Alas!” said the stranger, “what can I do to assist you? I will die in your defense; but I am unacquainted with the castle, and want—"

"Oh!" said Isabella, hastily interrupting him; "help me but to find a trap-door that must be hereabout, and it is the greatest service you can do me, for I have not a minute to lose."

Saying all these words, she felt about on the pavement, and dircted the stranger to search likewise, for a smooth piece of brass enclosed in one of the stones.

"That," said she, "is the lock, which opens with a spring, of which I know the secret. If we can find that, I may escape—if not, alas! courteous stranger, I fear I shall have involved you in my misfortunes: Manfred will suspect you for the accomplice of my flight, and you will fall a victim to his resentment."

"I value not my life," said the stranger, "and it will be some comfort to lose it in trying to deliver you from his tyranny."

"Generous youth," said Isabella, "how shall I ever requite—"

You get the idea. And perhaps a few paragraphs of these clichéd declamations—filled with ideas that were already a subject of ridicule long before Walpole was born—could be tolerated. But every conflict and conversation in the novel proceeds along these lines.

Yet readers can derive some value from reading The Castle of Otranto . I would encourage students to compare this tale with another story featuring a harried heir with a dangerous parent set in a haunted castle, namely Shakespeare's Hamlet . What could be more instructive than to observe one author treat these same plot ingredients with psychological insight and poetic imagination, and then compare the result with Walpole’s manipulation of stick figures pretending that they are characters in a book.

This raises the obvious question: why has a novel so poorly written earned a place in literary history? Well, if Walpole’s characters lack psychological insight, Walpole himself possessed it in abundance. He understood that the chivalric notions of the medieval period might have gone stale in intellectual circles, but that they still fascinated readers of romantic fiction. Indeed, even in the 21st century, a certain segment of the populace gets a jolt out of images of brave knights saving damsels while proclaiming fantastic speeches filled with archaic but idealistic notions.

In short, Walpole helped invent the modern gothic tale, a kind of play-acting animated by a stylized medievalism. Even better, he knew how to market the gothic concept. He even built his own Gothic castle, Strawberry Hill House in Twickenham, creating a stir in architectural circles that might be even more noteworthyl than his impact on literary matters. Even in Walpole’s lifetime, his castle was a tourist attraction— although visitors had plenty of real medieval castles they could visit, many preferred this phony imitation, a kind of theme park castle foreshadowing what you might see at Disneyland in the current day. Give Walpole credit for grasping the public's preference for faux medievalism over the real thing.

The plot of The Castle of Otranto is much the same, reeking of phoniness at every turn. Its best passages are empty formulas, and the worst veer into the ridiculous. In the opening pages, the heir of Otranto is killed on his wedding day when a giant helmet falls from the sky and squishes him into a pulp. The evil father now hatches an alternative plan for securing a male heir. Meanwhile a romantic young man with chivalric ideas show up on the scene, and makes many speeches about love, virtue and service to the beautiful princesses of the castle. Can you predict who will end up as the new master of Otranto by the end of the novel?

Walpole makes a token effort to surprise the reader with revelations about various matters, including the true lineage of the chivalrous young man. But they hardly surprise if you can see them coming a hundred pages in advance. The real shock for readers in these pages is how clumsy Walpole is at describing settings, events, characters and conflicts. Everything comes across as a reheated amalgamation of ingredients drawn from older works.

But never underestimate the public’s appetite for idealized romance. By comparison, a deep probing exploration of the real romantic lives of medieval couples would have been a commercial failure. For the same reasons, a more psychologically nuanced approach to these characters would have disappointed many readers. And, in all fairness, Walpole wasn't the first author who succeeded by aiming lower than his peers. Indeed, the very simplicity of the ingredients in this book explain why they have been borrowed so frequently by later writers.

Ted Gioia writes about music, literature and popular culture. His latest book is How to Listen to Jazz from Basic Books.

In the opening pages, the heir of Otranto is killed on his wedding day when a giant helmet falls from the sky and squishes him into a pulp.