Kazuo Ishiguro’s Never Let Me Go , stands out as a "classic instance of a story that's horrifying," Ramsey Campbell explains, "precisely because the narrator doesn’t think it is." Rachel Cusk makes the same point when, reversing a famous phrase, she describes the novel’s effect as based on "the evil of banality."
Yet other readers, perhaps deceived by the complacent complicity of the narrator and other victims in this book, don’t even see it as a horror tale. They have some justification is classifying it as a bildungsroman , or a philosophical novel—an exemplar of what John Gardner was calling for in his quasi-manifesto On Moral Fiction —or even a love story, built on that time-honored plot device, the romantic triangle.
Ishiguro earns our praise by crafting a lucid narrative that achieves all of these goals, yet without ostentation or any sense of tension between the different layers to his story. As I read Never Let Me Go , I marveled at the paradoxical nature of Ishiguro's achievement: the story wears a mask of blandness, yet I found the book a compelling 'page-turner'. In the realm of horror fiction, where so many of the leading figures in the field reach for success through excess, where taste and restraint are often tossed aside within the first ten pages and plot development proceeds as a kind of Bataan death march, Ishiguro’s skill stands out all the more.
Yet I avoided reading this novel for many years. And the author is to blame for my hesitancy. When Never Let Me Go was released Ishiguro gave away 'spoilers' in his interviews—or at least, I thought they were spoilers. He explained that his book was about a group of youngsters who lived in a boarding school, but their teachers weren't preparing them for careers. Instead, the ‘students’ would eventually supply organs for harvesting.
I naively assumed that I now knew the surprise ending of Never Let Me Go , and this would prevent me from savoring the suspense and mystery in the book. How wrong I was! In fact, everyone involved, including the students at Hailsham school, are aware from the outset that the endpoint for these children is a series of 'donations'. Yet Ishiguro still withholds crucial information—indeed, one of the most impressive aspects of this novel is the skill with which our author reveals so many details, while keeping others under wraps until the proper moment. He draws on a wide range of devices to achieve this, including huge leaps in narrative chronology, foreshadowing, flashbacks, symbols, false hypotheses shared by the characters, various red herring clues, and other methods of what magicians call 'misdirection'. Yet the whole narrative proceeds with such guileless ease—presented as a kind of diary of one of the students—that readers can easily miss the virtuosity demonstrated by our author again and again in these pages.
The surface story is simple enough. Our narrator Kathy relates her time at Hailsham, and focuses on her relationships with two classmates, her bossy friend Ruth and the loner boy Tommy. Occasionally other characters step briefly into the forefront of the tale, most notably the Guardians who fill the role of teachers at Hailsham. The reader quickly picks up on the creepy ambience at the school, but only gradually comes to notice the most unusual aspect of this suspense novel. Put simply, there is no apparent enemy here, no monster or slasher, no ghost or criminal, no vampire or zombie, nothing that goes bump in the night. Everybody has the best of intentions—or so it seems.
The mysteries presented in these pages are such tiny ones. Why does a woman show up every few weeks to scrutinize the youngsters’ artwork, and take away the best items for her 'gallery'? Why did one of the Guardians make that enigmatic statement in class, complaining that the students "had been told and not told" about their future? Why was she fired a few days later? And what about rumors that some students can get deferrals provided that they meet certain unspecified criteria?
As I look back at this novel, which I found filled with an almost unbearable tension even in scenes that are superficially free of conflict, I’m convinced that this pervasive tranquility is actually the key ingredient in Ishiguro’s success. Has anyone ever written a horror novel in which everyone is smiling and compassionate? You might assume that such a path to terror is a dead end road, but when actually confronted with a story of this sort, you may find it so unsettling that you even consider putting this book aside. Wouldn't it be better not to learn too much about the donations? Ah, you will keep reading….because you, too, will have had your compassion aroused, and will care deeply for our three main characters. Ishiguro has caught you in his web.
What makes it all the worse (or perhaps better, from a purely literary standpoint) is that this is one of the most plausible dystopian novels you will ever read. Hardly a week goes by without some news story about genetic modifications and altered life forms going viral on the web. While I was reading Never Let Me Go , the press was breathlessly describing a successful new program to 'grow' human organs inside pigs. This raises the obvious question: what if you could save more lives by growing human organs in humans?
This isn't the place to explore the ethical issues raised by genetic research. I will simply point out that our technology is advancing faster than our moral wisdom as a species, and that the shallow utilitarianism that seems to guide our scientists' actions in the current day—overheated Jeremy Bentham mixed in with a dose of Auguste Comte's positivism—will very likely take us to some strange and ugly endpoints. We are trying to set rules for 21st century advanced research with an unreconstructed 19th century ethical philosophy. But I hardly need to prod you to think about these matters. Ishiguro's book will do that much better than anything I could say.
And that’s real horror. This is why the compassion of the Guardians and others in the book is so bloody disturbing. Of all the terrible things done in the last hundred years, the very worst were perpetrated by idealists with lofty goals for human improvement. They just wanted to help. We need horror novels with 'villains' of that sort—not just because they are the scariest evil-doers of them, but also because it may help us to recognize them when they next show up in our midst. Then again, maybe they already have.
Ted Gioia writes about music, literature and popular culture. His latest book is How to Listen to Jazz from Basic Books.